A person discovers they are flagged at the border in a Western European state. The charge underlying the notice – framed in the requesting country's criminal code – has no equivalent in the state where they live or travel. As of late 2025, this situation arises with notable regularity in our practice, and the gap between the law as it appears on paper and the reality of how it is handled is wider than most people expect.
A Red Notice is a request to locate and provisionally detain a person with a view to extradition. It is not an arrest warrant and not a judicial decision. The absence of dual criminality – the requirement that the underlying conduct be criminal in both the requesting and the requested state – is one of the most substantive grounds on which red notice the absence of dual criminality challenges succeed before the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF), and also one of the most frequently misunderstood.
This page sets out a general pattern – not an account of any specific matter handled by NORTHLARK – illustrating what realistically decides such a challenge in a Western European context, and what it cannot achieve on its own.
The general pattern: how the situation typically arises
The requesting state – often a jurisdiction where abuse of office, "economic crimes" or tax-adjacent offences are defined in unusually broad terms – issues a domestic arrest warrant. The national bureau forwards a request for a Red Notice to INTERPOL. The notice is circulated to member countries worldwide. The individual, who may have relocated to Western Europe years earlier, is flagged the first time they cross an internal border or present a passport for any purpose.
The conduct alleged – say, a commercial decision taken by a corporate director, or a property transaction characterised as fraud – may not constitute a criminal offence under the law of the Western European state of residence. It may be a civil or regulatory matter there, or simply not an offence at all. That gap is the dual-criminality point.
What the person typically does not realise at this stage is that staying inside one friendly country is not a viable long-term position. A notice – or a diffusion circulated directly by the national bureau – reaches member countries worldwide. The problem travels with the passport.
What does a dual-criminality argument actually require before the CCF?
A dual-criminality argument before the CCF requires more than simply asserting that the charge does not exist in the requested state. The argument must be constructed with precision. The CCF examines whether INTERPOL's processing of the data complies with its own rules, including the data-quality and data-accuracy standards set out in the Rules on the Processing of Data (RPD). An argument that the notice is improperly maintained because it cannot, in substance, support extradition from a particular member state is a legitimate line – but it must be evidenced, not merely stated.
In practice, the file needs to include a careful analysis of the charge as characterised by the requesting state, a parallel analysis of the closest equivalent provision in the state of residence (or the state most likely to act on a provisional arrest request), and a reasoned explanation of the gap. A bare assertion that "this is not a crime here" rarely moves the CCF. A structured legal opinion, drawing on the RPD's data-accuracy requirements and on the principle that a notice should only be maintained where it can lawfully serve its stated purpose, stands on firmer ground.
Where the prosecution also carries markers of political character – a selective targeting of the individual, a prosecution commenced shortly after a change in government, or a pattern visible in how similarly situated persons are treated – Article 3 of INTERPOL's Constitution reinforces the dual-criminality point. The two arguments work together; neither is weakened by the presence of the other.
If you have recently discovered you are flagged at the border or that your name carries a red flag in international databases, a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files – and on what basis – is the logical first step. Contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com or through a secure channel.
What the absence of dual criminality cannot achieve on its own
Dual criminality is a necessary condition for extradition, not for the maintenance of a Red Notice. INTERPOL's system is not formally bound by extradition law. The CCF does not simply apply the extradition treaty of the state of residence. What it does is examine whether INTERPOL's own rules – including the RPD's standards on necessity and data quality – are met. A dual-criminality gap is highly material to that question. It is not, however, automatically decisive.
We tell clients what the published CCF reporting actually shows, including the delays. A deletion request is, under the applicable rules, to be decided within nine months of being found admissible. In practice, the timeline is real and the waiting period is not comfortable for someone whose banking relationships, visa renewals or travel plans are suspended in the interim.
There is also no appeal against a CCF decision. If the first file is weak, a second request requires genuinely new elements. A dual-criminality argument advanced without a supporting legal analysis, or without addressing the requesting state's likely counter-position, may fail – and that failure makes the subsequent review harder to build.
Does the political character of the prosecution matter here?
Often, yes. In our experience, the dual-criminality point and the Article 3 political-character point are frequently found together. A prosecution framed as fraud or embezzlement, where the underlying act was an ordinary business or regulatory decision, may be simultaneously weak on dual criminality (because the conduct is not criminal in the state of residence) and coloured by political motive (because the prosecution commenced under circumstances that suggest the aim was to pressure or discredit rather than to achieve genuine accountability).
The audience pain in these matters is almost always the same: the prosecution at home is political, and no one abroad can see that from the paperwork. A well-constructed CCF file addresses both the legal gap and the factual context. Evidence of selective prosecution, of the individual's political or commercial profile, and of the country-conditions affecting the requesting state's judicial independence all become relevant. Neither argument should be advanced in isolation.
A note on what this pattern is and is not
This page describes a general illustrative pattern drawn from the published literature on INTERPOL challenges, publicly available CCF guidance, and the accumulated experience of practitioners in this field. It is not a description of any specific matter handled by NORTHLARK or any other firm. No client identifiers, no case numbers, no transaction figures and no country-specific identifiers capable of identifying an individual appear here. Any resemblance to a specific person's situation is coincidental. If your situation resembles this pattern, the appropriate step is a confidential assessment of your own facts.
If an earlier request to the CCF has already been decided against you – and there is no appeal mechanism – the position is not necessarily closed. A fresh request built on new elements, or on a more carefully structured argument, is possible. That file needs to be built with the weakness of the first submission fully in mind.
Related
- What happens if we decline – how NORTHLARK assesses cases it cannot take on
- Beneficial owner profile – INTERPOL exposure specific to beneficial ownership structures
- Former official profile – how former public officials are targeted through INTERPOL channels
Frequently asked questions
Does this describe a case you handled?
No. This page describes a general illustrative pattern, not a specific matter handled by NORTHLARK or any other firm. It draws on publicly available CCF guidance and published materials. No client identifiers, case numbers or country-specific identifiers capable of identifying any individual appear on this page. If your situation resembles the pattern described, we recommend a confidential assessment of your specific facts.
How closely will my situation match this?
Dual-criminality challenges in Western Europe share common structural features, but the outcome in any specific file turns on the precise characterisation of the charge, the law of the relevant state of residence, the strength of the evidence, and whether additional grounds such as Article 3 political character are available. No two files are identical. A pattern page like this one can orient your thinking; it cannot substitute for an analysis of your own position.
What decides the outcome in files like this?
The quality of the legal file submitted to the CCF is the primary variable. A well-constructed submission addresses the dual-criminality gap with a reasoned comparative analysis, engages the RPD's data-accuracy and data-quality standards, and – where relevant – builds the Article 3 political-character argument in parallel. Critically, there is no appeal against a CCF decision, so a weak first file cannot easily be corrected later. The strength of the argument on first submission matters considerably.
About NORTHLARK
NORTHLARK is an independent international boutique. We act exclusively for individuals challenging INTERPOL Red Notices and diffusions before the CCF, and in related extradition proceedings. We have no affiliation with any other firm or network. In our practice before the CCF, we present to clients what the published reporting actually shows – including realistic timelines and the absence of any appeal mechanism – because honest advice is the only advice worth giving.
We act only on lawful mandates. We do not assist anyone in evading legitimate justice, and we accept instructions only where we see genuine grounds on the facts and the law. The first assessment is confidential. Our enquiry form does not require your real name, and you can reach us through a secure channel – Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp. For a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files and on what basis, contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com.
More in Case patterns
- In the CIS, what decides a challenge built on a human-rights bar
- In the CIS, what decides a challenge built on a political-motive finding
- In Western Europe, what decides a challenge built on the absence of a valid judicial basis
- In Western Europe, what decides a challenge built on recognised refugee status
Facing an unjustified Red Notice?
Free initial assessment. Challenging Interpol Red Notices and extradition defence.
Request an assessment