Dual criminality sounds straightforward on paper. If the conduct alleged in the requesting state is not a criminal offence in the state where you are living, the legal basis for a Red Notice ought to dissolve. As of autumn 2025, however, the pattern we see in Southern Europe shows that this argument succeeds only when it is prepared with precision – and fails, sometimes decisively, when it is not. The complexity matters before you act.
A Red Notice – sometimes called a "red corner notice" or described colloquially as being "on the INTERPOL list" or "blacklisted" – is a request to locate and provisionally detain a person with a view to extradition. It is not an international arrest warrant, and INTERPOL has no officers who arrest anyone. The challenge to red notice the absence of dual criminality is a recognised ground before the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF), but it requires specific legal architecture to succeed.
This page describes an illustrative general pattern observed in Southern Europe. It is not an account of any matter handled by this firm, and it does not represent any individual client.
What is the dual-criminality argument, and when is it available?
Dual criminality means that the conduct underlying the charge must amount to a criminal offence under both the law of the requesting state and the law of the state where the person is found. Where that condition is not met, the request lacks a proper legal foundation in the receiving state. Before the CCF, the argument runs differently: it is raised as a ground that the notice does not comply with INTERPOL's own rules governing data quality and the legitimate purpose of processing.
In practice, the argument is available at two distinct junctures. First, before the CCF, a person who is flagged at the border or who suspects they are wanted by INTERPOL can apply to have the notice deleted on the basis that the underlying offence does not exist in any meaningful equivalent form in the state of residence. Second, in extradition proceedings before the courts of the state of detention, the absence of dual criminality is a formal bar under most extradition laws in Southern Europe and under the general principle applied across council-of-Europe member states.
These are related but separate tracks. Winning before the CCF does not automatically terminate the extradition process, and a court victory on extradition does not automatically delete the notice. In our practice, conflating the two is one of the most common errors we see when a person has already been given poor advice, often – and we note this because it matters – from a scam operation that collected fees and delivered nothing. If you do not know who to trust after a first approach turned out to be a scam, that scepticism is entirely rational. No honest adviser asks for money to "remove" a notice through unofficial channels. There are none.
What does the pattern in Southern Europe actually look like?
The illustrative pattern runs as follows. A person is resident, or has relocated, to a Southern European state – Portugal, Spain, Italy, Greece or similar – and has built a settled life there. A notice was issued by a requesting state, often outside the European Union, for conduct that the requesting state classifies as fraud, embezzlement or abuse of office. The requesting state's definition of the offence is broad, and may capture commercial conduct that the Southern European state treats as a civil dispute or a regulatory matter, not a crime.
At border control – or during a routine police check, or when renewing a residence document – a red flag appears on the person's name. The person is detained for questioning, sometimes for several hours. In the more serious pattern, a provisional arrest is made. The question then becomes whether the dual-criminality bar can be raised quickly enough to prevent transfer.
Two features consistently shape whether the argument holds. The first is documentary: the person must be able to show, by reference to the law of the state of residence, that the conduct alleged does not meet the elements of any criminal offence there. This requires a legal opinion on the applicable national criminal law – not an assertion, a mapped analysis. The second is factual: the description of the conduct in the notice and in any extradition request must be examined carefully, because requesting states sometimes re-characterise conduct to fit dual-criminality requirements. Where that re-characterisation is inconsistent with the underlying case papers, it can be challenged.
In a recent illustrative pattern (a non-EU requesting state, an individual resident in Southern Europe, autumn 2024), the dual-criminality argument succeeded before both the CCF and the domestic court when the mapped legal analysis demonstrated that the alleged conduct was entirely addressed by the civil law of the state of residence. The notice was deleted and the extradition request was refused. The process took the better part of a year. There was no guarantee at the outset, and there should not have been one.
In a contrasting pattern (a different requesting state, a different Southern European jurisdiction, spring 2025), the argument failed at the CCF stage because the initial file relied on bare assertion rather than a mapped legal opinion. The CCF found no basis to depart from the notice. The person was left without the benefit of the nine-month review period running from a strong admissible request, and any later review would need to be built on entirely new grounds.
What can the dual-criminality argument not achieve?
This argument cannot resolve every problem. It does not address political motivation, data accuracy or human-rights concerns – separate grounds that may or may not exist in a given case. It does not prevent a requesting state from modifying the charge and issuing a fresh notice on a different legal basis. And it does not erase the fact that a notice was once circulated: the CCF can order deletion, but the history of the processing may remain in the records of border agencies that captured the data before deletion was ordered.
It is also important to be clear that there is no appeal against a CCF decision. If a first request is made poorly – with an incomplete file, an unsupported argument, or without the mapped legal analysis – and it fails, a subsequent request requires new elements. That window is not infinite. This is why the quality of the first file is the single most consequential decision in the process.
Is a dual-criminality challenge the right argument for your situation?
The argument is available only where the underlying conduct genuinely lacks an equivalent criminal offence in the state of residence. It is not a general escape route from a notice, and not every person who is "flagged at the border" or who feels "wanted by INTERPOL" has a dual-criminality case.
The honest answer – and we would rather give you the honest answer than a comfortable one – is that the assessment must be made before any action is taken. A challenge built on the wrong ground wastes the nine-month CCF review period and, in some cases, prejudices the extradition defence. We assess grounds before we agree to act. Where we do not see a genuine basis, we say so.
If you are uncertain whether a dual-criminality argument applies in your situation, the right first step is a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files, and an assessment of the grounds available. That check can be initiated before you give us your name.
Related
- Red Notice Removal – NORTHLARK's core CCF and extradition practice – how we assess and pursue deletion before the CCF
- Political Motive Pattern – CIS – illustrative pattern where Article 3 grounds succeeded in a CIS-origin matter
- Political Motive Pattern – MENA – illustrative pattern addressing political-character challenges from a MENA-origin notice
Frequently asked questions
Does this describe a case you handled?
No. This page describes a general illustrative pattern drawn from the type of situation that arises in Southern Europe when dual criminality is the central issue. It is not an account of any specific matter handled by NORTHLARK, and it does not identify any individual. We publish patterns of this kind to help people understand whether a recognised legal argument applies to their situation, before they take any step.
How closely will my situation match this?
Every matter is fact-specific. The pattern described here represents a common structure, but the applicable law of the state of residence, the precise description of the alleged conduct, and the requesting state's legal system all shape the analysis. A general pattern cannot substitute for an individual assessment. We would need to review the specifics before offering any view on whether the dual-criminality argument is available in your case.
What decides the outcome in files like this?
In our experience, the quality of the mapped legal analysis is the decisive factor. A bare assertion that the conduct is not criminal in the state of residence will not satisfy the CCF. What is required is a clear, documented comparison between the elements of the alleged offence under the requesting state's law and the criminal law of the state of residence, showing an absence of equivalence. The factual accuracy of the notice description is the second critical variable. A weak first file lowers the prospects of any later review, and there is no appeal once the CCF has decided.
About NORTHLARK
NORTHLARK is an independent international boutique acting exclusively for individuals before the CCF and in related extradition proceedings. We have no affiliations with any national firm or network. We act only on lawful mandates, and we take on a matter only where we see genuine grounds – if we do not see them, we say so plainly. For a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files and an initial assessment of the grounds available, contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com. The first assessment is confidential. Our enquiry form does not require your real name, and you can reach us through a secure channel – Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp.
More in Case patterns
- In Western Europe, what decides a challenge built on a human-rights bar
- In Western Europe, what decides a challenge built on a political-motive finding
- In Southern Europe, what decides a challenge built on the absence of a valid judicial basis
- In Southern Europe, what decides a challenge built on recognised refugee status
Facing an unjustified Red Notice?
Free initial assessment. Challenging Interpol Red Notices and extradition defence.
Request an assessment