Case Assessment
pattern

In the MENA region, what decides a challenge built on the absence of dual criminality

When the underlying conduct does not amount to a criminal offence in the country where the subject lives, the absence of dual criminality is one of the…

By 9 min readUpdated

A commercial relationship turns sour. The counterparty files a criminal complaint in their home jurisdiction. Months later, the individual – now living elsewhere – discovers they may be on the Interpol list, flagged at the border, or simply carrying an invisible red flag on their name that closes doors without explanation. As of mid-2025, this pattern recurs with particular frequency in cross-border matters originating from the MENA region. The lost opportunity is concrete: a business trip, a banking relationship, a residency application – each interrupted before the individual even knows why.

When the underlying conduct does not amount to a criminal offence in the country where the subject lives, the absence of dual criminality is one of the clearest grounds to challenge a Red Notice. Red notice the absence of dual criminality is not a procedural technicality; it strikes at the legitimacy of the notice itself, because INTERPOL's own framework requires that the conduct in question be punishable in both the requesting and the requested state. This page describes a general pattern – not any specific client matter handled by NORTHLARK – and explains what that ground can and cannot realistically achieve before the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF).

The sections below cover how the pattern typically arises, what makes the dual-criminality argument succeed or fail, how the CCF engages with it, and where the limits lie.

How does this pattern typically arise in the MENA region?

The pattern begins with a commercial dispute that one party converts into a criminal file. In several MENA jurisdictions, conduct that would be classified as a civil or contractual matter in most European or common-law systems – a failure to repay a debt, a disputed agency arrangement, an allegation of breach of fiduciary duty – can be charged under local criminal provisions relating to fraud, embezzlement or abuse of trust. The local NCB then submits a Red Notice request to INTERPOL's General Secretariat.

The subject, living or working in a jurisdiction where identical conduct would attract only civil liability, does not hear about the notice until something breaks: a border control officer requests detention, a bank asks unexpectedly searching questions, or a background check reveals they are wanted by Interpol. At that point, the individual is already at a disadvantage. Time has passed. The requesting state's file has been accepted. The notice – whether a formal red corner notice or a diffusion – is already circulating.

In our experience, the clients who arrive at this stage often carry the same initial belief: that because they found no result on INTERPOL's public website, they must be clear. That assumption is incorrect and costly. The public website carries only a fraction of active notices. Most are never made public. Being blacklisted by INTERPOL does not always mean your name appears in a public search.

What does the absence of dual criminality actually require you to show?

A successful dual-criminality argument before the CCF requires more than a bare assertion that "this would not be a crime at home." The CCF applies INTERPOL's Rules on the Processing of Data, and the data-quality and data-accuracy conditions within those rules demand that the underlying request be grounded in conduct that meets the threshold for a criminal offence in the state where extradition or surrender would be sought.

Three things must be established clearly.

  1. The conduct as alleged – not the label the requesting state places on it – must be mapped against the criminal law of the state of residence. This requires a precise legal opinion from qualified counsel in that jurisdiction, not a general statement that "commercial disputes are civil matters here."
  2. The characterisation of the conduct in the requesting state's file must be examined. Where a MENA jurisdiction has charged fraud on facts that amount to a simple unpaid debt, the actual underlying facts are what count, not the charge heading.
  3. The file submitted to the CCF must present these points coherently and with supporting documentation. The CCF decides on the file before it. A weak file submitted first can reduce the prospects of any later review, because there is no appeal against a CCF decision and a fresh request requires genuinely new elements.

In a recent matter of this type (a MENA-origin notice, first half of 2025), the dual-criminality analysis was the centrepiece of a successful CCF file. The conduct alleged – failure to transfer funds under a disputed agency contract – did not satisfy the elements of any criminal offence under the law of the subject's country of residence. The file demonstrated this by legal opinion, by comparative analysis of the charge, and by evidence of the civil proceedings already running in parallel. The CCF found the data did not comply with the applicable processing conditions.

For a confidential assessment of whether your situation fits this pattern, contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com or reach us through a secure channel (Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp).

Where does the dual-criminality ground fall short?

Dual criminality is not a universal solution. Several situations weaken or defeat the argument entirely.

First, if the alleged conduct does satisfy the elements of a criminal offence in the subject's country of residence – even under a different charge heading – the argument fails. The analysis must be honest. We have seen files where counsel asserted dual criminality on thin grounds; the CCF rejected them, and the subject lost the benefit of a first clean application.

Second, dual criminality alone does not address a notice that also carries grounds under Article 3 of INTERPOL's Constitution – the bar on notices connected to offences of a political, military, religious or racial character. Where both arguments apply, both should be advanced. Where only dual criminality applies, it is the entire case, and it must be airtight.

Third, a notice challenged purely on dual criminality may be reconstituted if the requesting state refiles on different or additional conduct. The challenge removes the present data; it does not permanently bar a requesting state from making a new, compliant request based on different facts.

Finally, even a successful deletion before the CCF does not automatically resolve a parallel diffusion, which is an alert circulated directly by a national bureau outside the formal notice system. Both instruments may need to be addressed, and the strategy for each can differ.

Does a CCF challenge address extradition directly?

A CCF challenge and an extradition defence are distinct proceedings, though they are closely connected. The CCF reviews the data INTERPOL processes; it does not rule on whether extradition should proceed. A successful deletion before the CCF removes the notice and the associated international alert. It does not, however, prevent a requesting state from pursuing extradition through bilateral treaty channels, without any INTERPOL notice at all.

Where extradition proceedings are also running – or where the subject has been provisionally arrested on the basis of a notice – the dual-criminality point is argued separately before the courts of the requested state, under that state's extradition law. In our practice, we coordinate both tracks where both are live, instructing allied counsel in the country of detention where domestic advocacy is required. The CCF track and the extradition track reinforce each other: a CCF deletion weakens the extradition request materially, but the extradition court applies its own standard.

This is an important limit to be clear about from the outset. No honest practitioner describes a CCF deletion as a guarantee that extradition will not proceed. What it does is remove the international mechanism that makes the subject locatable and detainable across borders, and it provides the extradition court with a strong independent finding that the underlying data was non-compliant.

If an earlier CCF application has already been refused, the position is harder – but not always closed. A new request requires genuinely new elements. Where new evidence of dual-criminality failure has emerged, or where the requesting state has disclosed additional facts that further undermine the notice, a second file may be viable. We review such situations individually, with care and without optimism that cannot be backed by the facts.

Please note: this page describes a general illustrative pattern for informational purposes. It is not an account of any specific matter handled by NORTHLARK, and it does not constitute legal advice on any individual's situation.

Related

  • Diffusion vs Red Notice – Understanding which instrument is circulating and why it matters for strategy
  • Company directors – How commercial disputes become notice exposure for directors and executives
  • Dual nationals – Specific risks and options when you hold nationality of the requesting state

Frequently asked questions

Is this a typical outcome?

Dual-criminality challenges succeed where the conduct alleged genuinely does not meet the criminal threshold in the subject's state of residence, and where the file presented to the CCF demonstrates this clearly with supporting legal analysis. The pattern described here is not rare, but outcomes vary considerably with the quality of the submission. There is no appeal against a CCF decision, so the first file must be well-constructed. No honest adviser can promise a specific result.

What would make my file weaker or stronger?

Stronger files are characterised by a precise, jurisdiction-specific legal opinion on the conduct as alleged, clear evidence of the factual background, and a coherent narrative that maps the actual acts onto the criminal-law elements of the residence state. Weaker files assert dual criminality without legal analysis, rely on the charge label rather than the underlying facts, or fail to address a parallel diffusion. A file submitted without adequate preparation is difficult to repair, because a fresh CCF request requires genuinely new elements.

Can this pattern be applied to my facts?

A pattern is a starting point, not a template. Whether the dual-criminality ground applies to your specific situation depends on the requesting state's charge, the law of your state of residence, the contents of the INTERPOL file, and whether a diffusion also exists alongside any formal notice. A confidential screening – asking what data INTERPOL holds about you – is often the correct first step. It carries no obligation and does not require you to disclose your identity in the first message.

About NORTHLARK

NORTHLARK is an independent international boutique. We act exclusively for individuals against unjustified INTERPOL Red Notices and diffusions before the CCF, and in related extradition proceedings. We work across jurisdictions, instructing allied counsel in countries of detention where domestic representation is required. We take on matters only where we see genuine grounds; we do not help anyone evade legitimate justice, and we are not affiliated with any external network or firm.

We treat confidentiality as the core of every engagement. A confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files – and on what basis – can be requested at any point. Our enquiry form does not require your real name. You can reach us at info@northlarkfirm.com, or through a secure channel (Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp), with no obligation beyond that first conversation.

Facing an unjustified Red Notice?

Free initial assessment. Challenging Interpol Red Notices and extradition defence.

Request an assessment

A confidential assessment of your case

Describe the situation in broad terms. We will come back with a preliminary view of the prospects before any commitment. The enquiry form does not require your real name; contact is also possible over Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp.

Email: info@northlarkfirm.com

Submitting this form places you under no obligation. The initial assessment is free and confidential. We act only on lawful mandates.