Imagine receiving a call from your attorney on a Tuesday morning: Ukrainian authorities have issued a request, the extradition from United States to Ukraine process has been formally initiated, and provisional arrest may follow. The treaty machinery is already moving. As of late 2024, the combination of an active Ukrainian extradition request and an INTERPOL Red Notice or diffusion is one of the most consequential cross-border situations a person in the United States can face – not because surrender is inevitable, but because the window for effective action closes faster than most people realise.
Extradition from United States to Ukraine proceeds under a bilateral treaty and the domestic law of the United States, governed by the federal extradition statute. An INTERPOL Red Notice circulated in parallel is a request to locate and provisionally detain a person with a view to extradition – it is not an arrest warrant and not a judicial decision. Both instruments must be challenged in parallel, through the federal courts and through the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) respectively. Understanding both channels is the first step.
This page explains the treaty architecture, the defences that carry genuine weight, how the INTERPOL dimension interacts with the judicial process, and what practical decisions are most consequential in the early weeks.
What is the treaty basis for extradition between the United States and Ukraine?
The United States and Ukraine operate under a bilateral extradition treaty, the relevant provisions of which establish the categories of extraditable offences and the procedural requirements for a valid request. The precise scope of that treaty matters immediately, because a request that does not satisfy its formal requirements on its face is a defective request – and defects are identified and argued before the federal district court handling the extradition proceedings.
In our practice, the first task when a request is received is to audit every element of the formal package: the translation, the certification, the description of the alleged offence, and the question of whether the conduct alleged falls within the treaty's extraditable-offence list. Ukrainian requests frequently concern charges framed under the Ukrainian criminal code in terms that do not map neatly onto a United States federal equivalent. That gap is the foundation of a dual-criminality argument, and it requires careful legal analysis at the outset.
It is worth being precise about what the federal proceedings are not. A section 3184 hearing is not a criminal trial. The magistrate or district judge does not weigh guilt or innocence. The court determines whether the treaty is in force, whether the subject is the person named, whether the offence is extraditable, and whether probable cause is established by the foreign evidence. Defence arguments at this stage focus on those specific questions – not on wider factual disputes about what happened in Ukraine.
Does dual criminality apply, and how does it work in practice?
Dual criminality – the requirement that the alleged conduct must be a criminal offence under the law of both the requesting and requested state – is one of the most substantive defences available in extradition from United States to Ukraine. It is not a technical loophole. It is a structural protection built into the treaty and the general law of extradition, and it reflects a principled limit on mutual legal assistance.
In the Ukrainian context, charges frequently carry labels – "abuse of office", "unlawful enrichment", "embezzlement of state property" – that sound familiar but define their elements differently under Ukrainian law. The question is not whether the same label exists in United States federal law, but whether the conduct described in the Ukrainian indictment or charge sheet, taken at its highest, would constitute a criminal offence under the law of the United States. Courts apply a conduct-based test.
Where the conduct alleged is essentially political – a decision made in office that the new government characterises as criminal, a commercial arrangement that a changed political context has re-labelled as fraud – dual criminality may fail on the facts, and the Article 3 argument before the CCF runs in parallel. We have seen requests from Ukraine where the same underlying events are simultaneously the subject of a commercial arbitration, a domestic criminal investigation and an INTERPOL diffusion. Maintaining a coherent legal position across all three requires that the team is aware of each strand.
For a confidential initial assessment of whether dual criminality and related grounds apply on the facts of your case, contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com. The first conversation is confidential, and you do not need to use your real name.
What human-rights defences are available?
Human-rights arguments in United States extradition proceedings occupy a specific procedural position. The federal extradition statute does not, by its terms, create a wide human-rights review at the certification stage. However, once a court has certified extraditability, the Secretary of State retains discretionary authority over surrender – and it is at that executive stage that human-rights conditions in the requesting state carry the most weight.
The condition of the Ukrainian justice system during and after the ongoing armed conflict is a matter of serious, documented concern. Defence of the home, displacement of the judiciary, disruption of the prison system, and the general conditions of detention are all factors relevant to the Secretary of State's discretion and to arguments framed around the principle of non-refoulement – the prohibition on returning a person to a state where they face a real risk of serious harm. These arguments are not speculative. They draw on country-condition evidence assembled from reliable public reporting and human-rights documentation.
Article 2 of INTERPOL's Constitution requires that INTERPOL's activities respect human rights in the spirit of the Universal Declaration. Article 3 bars INTERPOL from processing data connected to offences that are political, military, religious or racial in character. In our experience before the CCF, a well-evidenced Article 3 submission – supported by material showing that the prosecution reflects a change of government or a political rivalry rather than an ordinary criminal investigation – is among the most effective routes to deletion of a Red Notice or diffusion that runs alongside a United States extradition request.
The two processes reinforce one another. A favourable CCF decision does not bind the United States courts, but it changes the factual landscape. It puts a formal, independent international ruling on the record. Judges and secretarial decision-makers take note of that.
How does an INTERPOL Red Notice or diffusion interact with the extradition proceedings?
An INTERPOL Red Notice or diffusion does not create extradition proceedings, but it frequently precedes or accompanies them. The practical consequence is that the person named is flagged at the border in any INTERPOL member state, may be provisionally detained on arrival or in transit, and faces immediate restrictions on travel, banking and professional activity. You cannot plan travel, sign contracts or move money while this stands.
In this corridor, Ukrainian authorities commonly issue a diffusion – circulated directly by the Ukrainian National Central Bureau without passing through INTERPOL's standard notice approval process – before or alongside a formal extradition request. A diffusion is less visible than a Red Notice but carries substantially the same operational consequences at many border systems. A diffusion can also be challenged before the CCF, through the same request procedure as a Red Notice.
The CCF process is separate from and parallel to the federal extradition proceedings. A deletion or correction request is, under the applicable rules, to be decided within nine months of the request being found admissible. An access request – to learn whether data is held – is to be answered within four months. There is no appeal against a CCF decision; if the first request fails, a fresh application requires new elements. This makes the quality of the initial submission critical.
We coordinate with allied counsel in the country of detention where a client has been provisionally arrested outside the United States in connection with the same Ukrainian request. The strategy before the CCF and the strategy in the extradition proceedings must be consistent, and the evidence used in each must be prepared with the other in mind.
What is the rule of specialty, and does it matter here?
The rule of specialty provides that a person surrendered pursuant to an extradition treaty may be prosecuted, detained or extradited to a third state only for the offence for which extradition was granted. It is a treaty obligation binding on the requesting state – in this case, Ukraine – and a protection the person surrendered retains after transfer.
In the Ukrainian context, this matters because extradition requests sometimes name a specific charge, while the real interest of the Ukrainian authorities is a broader set of allegations. If Ukraine surrenders a person on a fraud charge and then adds charges of state treason or unlawful enrichment, the rule of specialty has been violated, and that violation would have consequences for any further extradition request Ukraine might make to a third state, as well as forming the basis of a complaint through diplomatic channels.
At the extradition stage in the United States, the defence can seek a condition in the certification or in the surrender instrument that formally limits Ukraine's authority to prosecute only for the named offence. Whether such conditions are enforceable in practice depends on diplomatic follow-through – but they are recorded, and their breach creates legal consequences.
Can someone on the INTERPOL list actually travel, and what happens at the border?
This is the question we hear most often, and the honest answer requires separating the legal position from the operational reality. Legally, an INTERPOL Red Notice does not oblige any country to arrest the named person. Each state decides under its own law and treaty obligations. Operationally, however, being flagged at the border – whether through a Red Notice or a diffusion – routinely results in secondary examination, temporary detention, and notification to the issuing National Central Bureau. The practical consequences of being on the INTERPOL list are therefore severe, even in states where no treaty with Ukraine would support actual surrender.
Travel to INTERPOL member states while a Red Notice or diffusion is live carries real risk. The United States itself will process the flag; travel within the United States is not generally constrained by an INTERPOL notice, but international travel from the United States becomes immediately problematic. Third-country travel – through a European hub, through Asia – carries the risk of provisional arrest and a separate extradition proceeding in that jurisdiction. That is not a hypothetical.
In a recent matter involving a CIS-origin notice and a Ukrainian ancillary diffusion (autumn 2024), we coordinated with allied counsel in the jurisdiction of provisional arrest and obtained a CCF deletion on Article 3 grounds after demonstrating that the underlying prosecution followed a change in the political leadership of the relevant Ukrainian state body. The person was released and the notice removed from the INTERPOL system. Each case turns on its own facts.
In a separate matter (a Central European state, early 2024), the extradition request failed at the dual-criminality stage because the Ukrainian charge of "abuse of official powers" did not correspond to any criminal offence under the law of the requested state. The CCF proceeding was resolved subsequently on data-quality grounds under the applicable provisions of INTERPOL's Rules on the Processing of Data. Again, the result is fact-specific.
The myth that waiting improves the position
A persistent belief in this area is that a Red Notice or extradition request will quietly lapse, or that silence from the requesting state means the matter has been dropped. This is incorrect, and acting on that belief has consequences that are difficult to reverse.
A Red Notice does not expire on a fixed date. INTERPOL's Rules on the Processing of Data include retention review provisions, but these are periodic and do not guarantee removal. An extradition request lodged with the United States authorities does not disappear because the person has not been arrested. It remains on file. The provisional arrest mechanism can be activated at any future border crossing or, in some circumstances, on the basis of a subsequent formal request.
There is no appeal against a CCF decision. A fresh request requires new elements. This means that a weak or poorly argued first submission to the CCF forecloses options for the future. No honest practitioner can guarantee that any given application will succeed. What we can say with confidence – and do say openly to every client we assess – is that a carefully built first file materially improves the prospects, and a hurried or incomplete one reduces them. If an earlier attempt has already failed, the analysis must begin with what was submitted and what was not.
There is likewise no appeal within the United States extradition process in the conventional sense. The proper moments to intervene are defined, and missing them is costly. The most consequential decisions are made in the first weeks after the request becomes known. We take on a matter only where we see genuine grounds, and we say so plainly when we do not.
If you are concerned that your name may be flagged in INTERPOL's systems – whether or not a formal extradition request has been served – contact us for a confidential check. We can assess whether data is held and advise on the most appropriate first step. Reach us at info@northlarkfirm.com or through a secure channel.
Related
- Extradition Defence – NORTHLARK's practice in cross-border extradition proceedings worldwide
- Detained at an Airport: Hong Kong – what happens when you are stopped in transit on a Red Notice
- Detained at an Airport: Singapore – provisional arrest in Singapore and how the process unfolds
Frequently asked questions
Can I be released or bailed during proceedings?
Bail in federal extradition proceedings in the United States is possible but treated restrictively. The federal courts apply a high standard for release, and the government typically argues that any person subject to an extradition request presents a flight risk. Release pending the outcome of extradition proceedings is not impossible, but it requires a specific factual and legal argument – often addressing ties to the jurisdiction, absence of a prior criminal record, and the substantive merits of the defence. Representation from the outset materially affects this outcome.
Does dual criminality apply to my case?
Dual criminality applies in extradition from the United States to Ukraine: the conduct alleged must constitute a criminal offence under United States federal law as well as Ukrainian law. The test is conduct-based, not label-based. Ukrainian charges such as "abuse of office" or "unlawful enrichment" do not automatically satisfy the dual-criminality requirement. Whether your specific case raises a credible dual-criminality argument depends on the precise conduct described in the Ukrainian charging documents, assessed against the applicable United States federal offences.
What is the rule of specialty and does it help me?
The rule of specialty is a treaty obligation that limits Ukraine to prosecuting only the offence for which extradition was granted. It prevents Ukraine from adding charges after surrender for conduct not covered by the original extradition request. In practice, it is most useful as a negotiated condition in the surrender instrument and as a basis for diplomatic or legal complaint if violated after transfer. It does not, on its own, block extradition, but it is a meaningful protection worth asserting in the proceedings.
About NORTHLARK
NORTHLARK is an independent international boutique acting exclusively for individuals facing unjustified INTERPOL Red Notices, diffusions and related extradition proceedings. We are not affiliated with any firm, network or parent practice, and our independence is a structural feature of the service we provide – particularly for clients whose notices originate from the CIS or from states where political motivation in prosecution is a live issue. In our practice before the CCF and in extradition proceedings across multiple jurisdictions, we act only on lawful mandates where we see genuine grounds; we do not take on matters where the honest assessment is that the underlying prosecution reflects legitimate law enforcement. The first assessment is confidential. Our enquiry form does not require your real name, and you can reach us through a secure channel – Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp – as well as by email at info@northlarkfirm.com. If you are concerned that you may already be flagged in INTERPOL's systems, a confidential check of whether data is held – and what it says – is the right first step.
More in Extradition corridors
Facing an unjustified Red Notice?
Free initial assessment. Challenging Interpol Red Notices and extradition defence.
Request an assessment