Case Assessment
corridor

Extradition from Italy to Belarus: the defence

Extradition from Italy to Belarus refers to the legal process by which Italian authorities may be asked to arrest and surrender a person to the Belarusian…

By 14 min readUpdated

A Belarusian extradition request does not announce itself quietly. It arrives as a detention at Fiumicino, a call from a consular official, or a formal notification to the Italian Ministry of Justice after years of apparent calm. The complexity of defending this corridor lies not in any single rule but in the intersection of Italian extradition procedure, European human-rights standards, INTERPOL data, and the specific conditions prevailing in Belarus as of late 2025. Understanding each layer before the first hearing is the difference between a coherent strategy and an improvised one.

Extradition from Italy to Belarus refers to the legal process by which Italian authorities may be asked to arrest and surrender a person to the Belarusian state following a formal extradition request or, in many cases, an INTERPOL Red Notice. Italy will not surrender a person automatically; every request must satisfy Italian extradition law, bilateral treaty conditions, and binding European human-rights obligations. Each of those layers is a potential ground of refusal.

This page examines the treaty basis, the hearing process in Italy, the human-rights and dual-criminality defences, the interaction with a Red Notice, and the practical shape of a strong defence.

What is the treaty basis for extradition between Italy and Belarus?

Italy and Belarus do not have a dedicated bilateral extradition treaty in force, which means that any Belarusian request must proceed on a different legal footing. In the absence of a treaty, Italian law governs the conditions for extradition as a matter of domestic statute. That statute embeds human-rights protections directly: surrender may be refused where there is a real risk that the person would be subjected to persecution, torture, or treatment incompatible with Italy's constitutional and international obligations. This is not a discretionary courtesy but a legal threshold the requesting state must, in substance, clear.

Belarus is not a Council of Europe member state and is not party to the European Convention on Human Rights. That absence matters enormously. Italian courts have no mechanism to rely on a reciprocal commitment from Minsk to respect the rights protected by European instruments. In our practice, that structural gap is one of the first points we raise before the relevant court of appeal – the Corte di Appello – because it shifts the evidential weight of the human-rights inquiry decisively in the client's favour.

A further consequence of the treaty gap is that the Belarusian request must satisfy Italian procedural formalities for extradition without treaty: the documentation submitted must be complete, properly translated and authenticated, and it must show that the underlying offence meets the requirements Italian law imposes. Where documentation is deficient – and in our experience before this corridor, deficiencies are common – that alone can ground a successful challenge at the admissibility stage.

How does dual criminality apply in this corridor?

Dual criminality is satisfied when the conduct alleged by Belarus would also constitute a criminal offence under Italian law. Italy applies the conduct-based form of this test: what matters is whether the facts, stripped of their Belarusian legal classification, would be punishable in Italy – not whether the two legal systems use the same charge name. This distinction has real consequences for Belarusian requests.

Belarus has prosecuted individuals for offences that have no equivalent in Italian law, or that carry a very different meaning. "Discrediting the state", "extremism" applied to political activity, and aggravated forms of civil-society participation are examples of charges that regularly appear in Belarusian request documents and that may not correspond to any conduct punishable in Italy. Where dual criminality is absent, Italian courts must refuse the request. The analysis is genuinely fact-specific – the description of the alleged conduct in the request documents is the operative text.

In a matter we handled involving a CIS-origin notice (spring 2025), the underlying charge had been translated to resemble an economic crime, but a close reading of the request documentation revealed that the conduct was participation in a lawful civil society organisation. The court agreed that the dual-criminality condition was not satisfied, and the proceedings were terminated at that stage. The lesson is that the charge name on a Belarusian request document is never the end of the analysis.

What are the human-rights grounds for resisting surrender to Belarus?

The human-rights ground is, in current conditions, the most powerful argument available in this corridor. Italian law, reinforced by the European Convention on Human Rights as applied in Italy's domestic order, prohibits surrender where there are substantial grounds to believe the person would face a real risk of torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, or a flagrantly unfair trial in the requesting state. The threshold is not proof beyond reasonable doubt; it is substantial grounds, assessed against credible country-conditions evidence.

The conditions in Belarus since 2020 are extensively documented by international human-rights bodies. Systematic ill-treatment in detention, politically motivated prosecutions, and the absence of independent judicial oversight are matters of record in publicly available reporting from the United Nations Human Rights Council and the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, among others. A defence file that marshals this reporting – and connects it to the specific profile and alleged conduct of the client – is, in our experience, the most persuasive form of the human-rights argument.

The argument is reinforced where the client holds refugee or subsidiary-protection status in Italy or another EU state. Non-refoulement is a recognised principle of international law barring return to a state where there is a risk of persecution. Italian courts treat a positive protection decision as highly material to the extradition assessment, though not technically dispositive. Surrender to a state from which a person has been recognised as fleeing persecution would be, in substance, a violation of that protection. We always advise clients to pursue protection proceedings in parallel where they have not already done so.

The obligation on the Italian state is to conduct an individualised assessment. General country-conditions evidence is necessary but not sufficient. The file must show why this person faces a real risk – their political profile, prior treatment, the nature of the alleged conduct, the documented practices of the prosecuting agency. Assertion without evidence rarely succeeds. Evidence without argument never does.

If you have recently been told that Italian proceedings have been opened following a Belarusian request, the time to act is before provisional detention is ordered, not after. For a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files and whether a request has been formally registered, contact us at info@northlarkfirm.com or through a secure channel.

What happens at a first extradition hearing in Italy?

The first hearing before the court of appeal determines two things: whether the formal conditions for the proceedings to continue are met, and whether the person should be held in provisional detention pending a full hearing on the merits. It is not yet the substantive hearing on whether to surrender. But it is not merely procedural either – the positions taken at the first hearing shape the trajectory of everything that follows, and the court will have already formed a preliminary view of the documentation.

The court will examine whether the request is formally complete, whether the alleged offence is extraditable in principle, and whether there are obvious bars to proceeding. Defence counsel must appear at this stage. An absent or unprepared defence at the first hearing often means provisional detention, which changes the client's practical position entirely. In our practice, we ensure that allied counsel in Italy are instructed well before the first hearing date is scheduled, so that the documentary foundation is laid in advance, not assembled under time pressure.

The client has the right to be heard. Statements made at this stage are part of the record. They must be consistent with the defence strategy and with any parallel CCF proceedings. An uncoordinated statement before the Italian court can damage both the extradition defence and the position before the Commission. Preparation is not optional.

How does the Red Notice interact with the Italian proceedings?

A Belarusian Red Notice is a request by the Belarusian National Central Bureau, circulated through INTERPOL, to locate and provisionally detain the person with a view to extradition. It is not an arrest warrant and not a judicial decision. It does not oblige Italy or any other state to act. Each state decides what, if anything, to do when it encounters a notice, under its own domestic law. In Italy, the discovery of a Red Notice may trigger a provisional arrest, but that arrest is subject to the same judicial review as any other arrest in extradition proceedings.

The practical reality is that a Red Notice is what causes the stop at the border, the account closure before any question is asked, and the flag on banking or travel systems. The person who is "on the Interpol list", "blacklisted", or has a "red flag on their name" is living with consequences that follow from the Notice, not from any Italian judicial decision. That distinction – between the INTERPOL data layer and the Italian legal proceedings – is important because the two tracks can and should be challenged simultaneously.

INTERPOL's own rules, set out in its Constitution, establish limits on what the organisation may process. Article 3 of INTERPOL's Constitution bars processing of data connected to offences of a political, military, religious or racial character. Article 2 requires INTERPOL's activity to respect human rights. Where a Belarusian prosecution falls within Article 3 – as political prosecutions frequently do – the Commission for the Control of INTERPOL's Files (CCF) has jurisdiction to order deletion of the notice. A successful CCF application removes the INTERPOL data layer and eliminates the notice as a tool of enforcement, even if the Belarusian request continues at a diplomatic or bilateral level.

In a recent matter (a Belarus-origin notice, winter 2024–2025), we successfully pursued the CCF track concurrently with the Italian extradition defence. The notice was deleted following a file that demonstrated the political character of the underlying prosecution. The formal extradition proceedings in Italy were subsequently withdrawn by the requesting state. The two tracks are legally independent, but in practice they reinforce each other.

Does asylum or refugee status in Italy change the position?

Yes, materially. Italian courts treat a formal protection decision – whether refugee status or subsidiary protection – as a strong indicator that the human-rights threshold for refusing extradition is met. The protection decision reflects a prior determination, by a specialised Italian authority applying international standards, that there is a real risk of persecution or serious harm in Belarus. That finding is directly relevant to the extradition court's assessment.

The protection decision is not, technically, binding on the extradition court, but it would be a very unusual Italian court that disregarded it entirely. The practical weight is significant. Where a client does not yet have protection status, we assess whether an application is viable and, if so, advise that it be pursued without delay. Protection proceedings and extradition proceedings run on different tracks in Italian law; one does not automatically suspend the other, but the two interact in ways that a co-ordinated defence can use.

The principle of non-refoulement under international law applies independently of whether formal status has been granted. An Italian court is required to conduct its own human-rights assessment even in the absence of a protection decision. But a protection decision held at the time of the extradition hearing is a powerful piece of evidence that the Italian state's own specialised tribunal has already considered and accepted the risk.

A myth worth correcting: "the request is for someone else with the same name"

A common assumption – one we encounter regularly – is that a stop at the border or an account closure must be a case of mistaken identity because the name is common. This assumption is almost always wrong, and acting on it wastes the time that matters most. INTERPOL's data includes date of birth, passport details and other identifying information. A false-positive stop is possible, but it is the exception, not the default. The more dangerous position is the person who is genuinely listed and who loses weeks pursuing the identity-confusion angle instead of the legal one.

The correct first step is to verify, through a formal access request to the CCF, whether data is actually held and in what form. Under the applicable rules, an access request is to be answered within four months of being found admissible. That is the authoritative answer. Any other assumption is speculation, and speculation is not a defence strategy.

If you have reached this stage of the page having wondered whether the flag might be a mistake, the answer is: find out formally. Once you know what is held, the picture is clear. Until then, it is not.

A second submission to the CCF after an unsuccessful first request requires new elements. The absence of an appeal mechanism means that the quality of the first file is decisive. If an earlier request was made without specialist representation, or on incomplete grounds, we can advise on whether sufficient new material exists to support a fresh request.

Related

Frequently asked questions

What happens at a first extradition hearing?

The first hearing before the Italian court of appeal examines whether the formal conditions for the proceedings are met and whether provisional detention should be ordered. It is not yet the full substantive hearing, but positions taken here shape the entire case. Defence counsel must be present and prepared. The court will look at completeness of documentation, whether the alleged offence is extraditable in principle, and whether any obvious legal bar applies. A poorly managed first hearing frequently results in detention, which changes the practical reality of the defence.

Can extradition be refused on human-rights grounds?

Yes. Italian law and Italy's international obligations prohibit surrender where there are substantial grounds to believe the person faces a real risk of torture, inhuman treatment, or a flagrantly unfair trial in the requesting state. For Belarus, country-conditions evidence from credible international bodies supports this argument strongly in current circumstances. The assessment must be individualised: the client's specific profile, the nature of the alleged conduct, and the practices of the relevant Belarusian authorities must all be addressed.

How does the Red Notice affect the request?

A Red Notice is what triggers the practical consequences – border stops, account closures, travel flags. It is a request to locate and provisionally detain, not an arrest warrant, and it does not oblige Italy to act. The Notice can be challenged before the CCF on grounds including Article 3 of INTERPOL's Constitution, which bars data connected to political offences. A successful CCF application deletes the INTERPOL data independently of the extradition proceedings. Both tracks should be pursued concurrently where possible.

About NORTHLARK

NORTHLARK is an independent international boutique acting exclusively for individuals subject to INTERPOL Red Notices, diffusions, and cross-border extradition proceedings. We have no affiliation with any national firm, network or state-linked practice, which matters when the requesting state is Belarus or any other government with the means to identify or pressurise legal representation. In our practice, we tell clients what the published CCF reporting actually shows – including the delays, the limits of what a first file achieves, and the honest assessment of available grounds – because accuracy is the foundation of any defence.

We accept matters only where we see genuine legal grounds. We do not assist anyone in evading legitimate justice, and we will say so plainly if we cannot take a case. The first assessment is confidential: our enquiry form does not require your real name, and you may reach us on Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp as well as by email at info@northlarkfirm.com. For a confidential check of whether you are in INTERPOL's files and whether a formal request has been registered in Italy, please contact us through any of those channels.

Facing an unjustified Red Notice?

Free initial assessment. Challenging Interpol Red Notices and extradition defence.

Request an assessment

A confidential assessment of your case

Describe the situation in broad terms. We will come back with a preliminary view of the prospects before any commitment. The enquiry form does not require your real name; contact is also possible over Signal, Telegram or WhatsApp.

Email: info@northlarkfirm.com

Submitting this form places you under no obligation. The initial assessment is free and confidential. We act only on lawful mandates.